Pros and Cons -- Xamarin vs React Native vs Ionic vs Flutter vs PhoneGap vs Appcelerator Titanium -- Which One is Right for You?
Do you need to create a modern mobile app for your business? You can quickly build high-quality apps using app development frameworks, such as Xamarin, React Native, Ionic, Flutter, PhoneGap, and Appcelerator Titanium.
If you don’t have app development skills, you don’t have to worry! Get in touch with us and we will develop an amazing mobile app for you using the technology of your choice at an affordable price. Tempest House is the best development house in California. We’re an affordable software development agency. We have in-house experts and experienced freelance app developers from all across the globe. We also have designers and managers who can make sure your app is built with awesome designs and that it gets completed on time.
You can also hire a freelance developer, but if you hire a professional app development company like Tempest House, you can be sure that your project will be finished on time as we have a great team of experienced full-time and part-time developers working for us. So if someone is unavailable or sick, we can assign the work to someone else. This way, we can ensure timely delivery.
But which mobile app development framework should you select for your next app project? It’s very easy to get confused as all of these app development tools are very popular. Every framework in this list seems to be great.
But which one would be right for you?
In this blog post, we’re going to compare Xamarin, React Native, Ionic, Flutter, PhoneGap, and Appcelerator Titanium so it becomes easy for you to choose the right app development technology for you. By taking a look at the pros and cons of each of these technologies, you can quickly understand which one would be the best for you.
Xamarin
[Image source: Xamarin's official site]
Released on May 16 of 2011, Xamarin is a hot mobile app development technology that can be your favorite tool for creating mobile apps fast. It’s a brainchild of Microsoft. Using this app development weapon, you can create different types of apps including mobile games with amazing interfaces. Xamarin allows you to create apps for a variety of platforms, such as Windows, iOS, Android, Blackberry, macOS, watchOS, and tvOS.
The language of Xamarin is C#. So you have to write C# code for building Xamarin apps.
Xamarin app development in Visual Studio:
[Image source: Xamarin's official site]
You can find Xamarin’s official website here and its GitHub page can be viewed here.
You need to install Visual Studio to build apps with Xamarin. Here’s the link to get Visual Studio.
Interest over time
This chart shows that Xamarin has a pretty good popularity over the last 5 years.
Interest by region
The above chart from Google Trends shows that this framework has greatest popularity in regions such as North Macedonia, China, Belarus, Cyprus, and El Salvador.
Customer showcase
Some of the popular companies that are using this framework are UPS, Outback Steakhouse, Allscripts, HCL, Aggreko, Olo, Taxfyle, FreshDirect, BBVA, American Cancer Society, BBC Good Food, Just Giving, and so on.
[Image source: Xamarin’s official site]
Pros of Xamarin
Open-source framework: Xamarin is a completely free and open-source framework that has more than 60,000 contributors striving hard to improve it. Because of its open-source nature, you can also contribute to the software.
Great app speed: Xamarin apps are super fast. When you build a mobile app using this framework, you get a native mobile app. This is one of the most impressive benefits of Xamarin. Through hardware acceleration and native APIs access, you get an app that executes smoothly.
Cross-platform app development: You can build several apps for various mobile phone operating systems like Android, Windows, and iOS from the single codebase. This saves you a huge amount of time as you don’t need to work on multiple separate projects. Work on just one project, and from that, you can generate apps for multiple platforms. You can share more than 75% of code across different platforms using this app development tool.
Cons of Xamarin
- Xamarin is not a great choice for game development.
- You need to purchase Visual Studio to write Xamarin code.
- There are many OS-specific limitations.
React Native
[Image source: React Native’s official site]
Released in March of 2015, React native is an awesome, free, open-source mobile app development framework developed by Facebook and its community. This tool lets you build Android and iOS apps.
React Native app development:
[Image source: React Native’s official site]
You can find the official website of React Native here and the GitHub page here.
For making apps with React Native, you have to write code in JavaScript and React.
Cross-platform app development:
[Image source: React Native’s official site]
Interest over time
The above chart shows that React Native’s popularity is increasing.
Interest by region
The above chart from Google Trends demonstrates that this framework has greatest popularity in regions such as China, Mongolia, Cambodia, and Sri Lanka.
App showcase
This mobile app development tool has been used to create many modern, popular apps, such as Facebook Ads Manager, Instagram, Facebook Analytics, Facebook, Skype, Oculus, Bloomberg, Tesla, Pinterest, Walmart, Uber Eats, Artsy, Wix.com, Salesforce, Vogue, and so on.
[Image source: React Native’s official site]
You can see a long list of open-source React Native apps here.
Pros of React Native
Near-native performance: You will get amazing performance with React Native. Apps built with this framework are not hybrid apps or HTML5 apps or mobile web apps. They're real mobile apps in that they utilize actual native visual components instead of HTML in their interfaces. This is one of the greatest advantages of using React Native.
Great app development speed: Another great advantage of using react-native is that you can build your mobile app very fast. This feature is called hot reloading. It allows you to reload your app instantly and you do not have to recompile your code again and again. This saves you a great amount of time and energy.
Optimization with native code: You can optimize the performance of your React Native app to a great extent by adding native code to your application. So you can build some features of your mobile app using React Native and some other features using native code. This greatly enhances the speed of your app.
Cons of React Native
- Although React Native apps are very fast, they are not as fast as truly native apps.
- Large app size is one of the many problems of React Native.
- To implement some native functionalities, you need native development skills. Adding native code increases the complexity of the project and hence will take more development time.
Ionic
[Image source: Ionic’s official site]
Released in 2013, Ionic is one of the best mobile app development tools available on the market. This free and open source app development technology allows you to create Windows, iOS, and Android apps.
Ionic components:
[Image source: Ionic’s official site]
For making apps with Ionic, you have to write code in HTML5, JavaScript, Angular JS, and CSS.
Fast apps:
[Image source: Ionic’s official site]
You can visit the official website of this technology by clicking here and find the GitHub page here.
Easy access to native functionalities:
[Image source: Ionic’s official site]
Interest over time
This chart shows that Ionic’s popularity is pretty good over the last 5 years.
Interest by region
The above Google Trends chart demonstrates that Ionic is very popular in regions such as China, Singapore, United States, Philippines, and Sri Lanka.
Customer showcase
Ionic is used and loved by great companies such as National Health Service, NASA, BMW, Amtrak, AAA, and Airbus.
[Image source: Ionic’s official site]
[Image source: Ionic’s official site]
Some of the top apps built with Ionic are SWORKIT, InstantPot, Shipt, UNTAPPD, etc.
Pros of Ionic
Ease of use: Ionic is extremely easy to use. You can quickly build mobile apps using the drag-and-drop feature and pre-built components of the technology. There are also plugins of this framework which allow you to easily create a great mobile app.
Flexible development environment: You can write code almost effortlessly using the code editor that resides inside the Ionic Creator and can also use other text editors and IDEs like Atom, Visual Studio Code, Sublime Text, and so on.
Great app speed: One of the exciting benefits of using Ionic is that you will be able to create high-performance mobile apps with this tool. Features such as AOT compiling, hardware accelerated transitions, pre-rendering, and touch-optimized gestures make your app run smoothly.
Cons of Ionic
- Ionic does not give good performance for graphic-heavy apps.
- Although there are many plugins for native functionalities, you won’t find plugins for every native feature. In that case, you need to create your plugin which will take a lot of time.
Flutter
[Image source: Flutter’s official site]
Flutter is a fantastic mobile app development framework developed by Google. Using this tool, you can build Android and iOS apps. This is a free and open source mobile app development framework.
Dart code:
[Image source: Flutter’s official site]
For Flutter app development, you need to write code in a language known as Dart which looks similar to modern programming languages such as JavaScript.
Flutter app development:
[Image source: Flutter’s official site]
Interest over time
Flutter’s popularity is gradually increasing.
Interest by region
Flutter is popular in regions like China, Nepal, and Cambodia.
Customer showcase
Flutter is used by realtor.com, Tencent, Square, The New York Times, Google Assistance, etc. It’s trusted by big brands such as Google, ebay, BMW, SONOS, GROUPON, CapitalOne, and so on.
Some of the modern applications built with this framework are Reflectly, Insight Timer, Google Ads, Grab, STADIA, Abbey Road Studios, Alibaba Group, ByteDance, Baidu, Hamilton, Greentea, and so on.
[Image source: Flutter’s official site]
Apps built with Flutter:
[Image source: Flutter’s official site]
[Image source: Flutter’s official site]
Let's take a look at the pros and cons of this technology now.
Pros of Flutter
Fast app development: You can build mobile apps using Flutter pretty fast. Just like React Native, you can use the hot reloading feature in this framework, also. This tool offers you amazing widgets for making rich UIs quickly.
Awesome performance: Flutter allows you to create fast mobile apps. As you can use native code in your app project, you can greatly speed up your app. Using the inbuilt widgets, you can implement high-quality icons, navigation, fonts, and scrolling. So you will get smooth performance.
Rich UIs: Flutter lets you create rich user interfaces for your mobile app. This framework’s built-in Material Design allows you to make designs that’s appealing to the eye. Rich motion APIs, Cupertino widgets, and smooth scrolling are some of the features that will impress you.
Cons of Flutter
- Flutter is rich with libraries but it doesn’t have libraries for all the functionalities that you need. As you won’t find ready-made libraries for some features, you need to develop them, which is a time-consuming process.
- It does not have great support for Cl platforms such as Jenkins and Travis. So you need to use custom scripts for automatic testing, builds, and deployment.
PhoneGap
[Source: PhoneGap’s official site]
PhoneGap is a powerful mobile app development tool that enables fast app development. With this framework, you can create apps for Window, iOS, Blackberry, and Android.
This tool allows you to write code in HTML, CSS, and JavaScript.
PhoneGap’s official website can be found here and you can see the GitHub page here.
Some of the famous apps developed using this framework are FanReact, TripCase, snowbuddy, Sworkit, Localeur, BrowserQuest, Untappd, Bit Timer, METAR Reader, My Heart Camera, and so on.
Interest over time
PhoneGap’s popularity is decreasing over time.
Interest by region
This framework has great popularity in China, Lebanon, Hong Kong, Nepal, Tunisia, etc.
App showcase
Some popular PhoneGap apps are FanReact, Sworkit, BrowserQuest, snowbuddy, Localeur, TripCase, Bit Timer, Untappd, and so on.
[Source: PhoneGap’s official site]
Pros of PhoneGap
Fast app development: If you’re looking to build mobile apps very fast, choose PhoneGap as it lets you quickly complete your development work. There are many tools available that improve productivity, which are PhoneGap CLI, PhoneGap Developer mobile app, PhoneGap Desktop app, and PhoneGap Build.
Open-source tool: PhoneGap is an open-source and free framework. So you don’t have to spend money for using this tool. There are a great number of active developers that are working to make this tool better.
Cross-platform app development: Using this great app development tool, you can build cross-platform apps, meaning you can produce apps for more than one platform from just one codebase.
Cons of PhoneGap
- A PhoneGap app’s performance is not as good as that of a truly native mobile app.
- PhoneGap is not a good fit for game development.
- You may not get plugins for every essential feature.
Appcelerator Titanium
[Source: Titanium’s official site]
Released on November 25 of 2019, Appcelerator Titanium is another great mobile app development framework that can be used for fast app development. This framework lets you build cross-platform apps for various mobile operating systems such as Windows, Android, and iOS.
Cross-platform app development:
[Source: Titanium’s official site]
For building a Titanium app, you need to write code in JavaScript.
There are premium and free versions available for this app development tool. You can see the plans here.
Titanium’s dashboard:
[Source: Titanium’s official site]
PhoneGap’s push notification service:
[Source: Titanium’s official site]
Interest over time
This framework’s popularity is decreasing over time.
Interest by region
Customer showcase
Titanium is trusted and used by popular companies such as vmware, cisco, zipcar, AVIS, blackbaud, FIS, T Mobile, Homes.com, Arrow, Waste No Good, Skydrop, Virgin Money, Oneok, and so on.
[Source: Titanium’s official site]
[Source: Titanium’s official site]
Pros of Titanium
Drag-and-drop feature: The drag-and drop feature of this mobile app development framework allows you to build apps very fast. Even if you do not have much experience of software development, you can quickly build a mobile app using this great tool.
Pre-built push notification service: If you want to show notifications to your mobile app users, you can easily do so by using the pre-built push notification service of Titanium.
Mobile app development using JavaScript: One of the great benefits of using Titanium is that you can build mobile apps using your existing knowledge of JavaScript. If you already know JavaScript, you do not have to learn a new language. This will save you a huge amount of time.
Cons of Titanium
- Titanium offers you a free version of this framework but it does not give you all the features and facilities. So you are bound to purchase the premium version of this mobile app development framework.
- With this mobile app development tool, you can build only simple apps. It's not a great choice for making complex apps.
- There are some SDK related issues that you may face while using Titanium.
So which framework should you choose?
Although all the mobile app development frameworks mentioned in this post are great, not all of them would be the right fit for your work.
Take a close look at the pros and cons and see which benefits of a framework you’re most interested in and which cons are really big issues for you. Also, see in which language(s) you have to write code to build apps using a particular framework and see if you’re comfortable with those languages because learning a new language can take a lot of time.
While selecting a framework for your business, you should consider important comparison factors such as development time, app performance, ease of use, and so on.
If you’re looking for a top outsourcing agency, please feel free to get in touch with us.
.png "Follow us on Facebook!"){kind=small}